The first things that come to mind when I think of the food scene in Las Vegas are celebrity chef restaurants, buffets, and fine dining. I’ve lost track of how many restaurants Gordon Ramsay has in Vegas. Even though you can find every type of food here, one type of food that is rarely mentioned is pizza. While Las Vegas isn’t known as a pizza town, you can find great pizza all around the city. This includes on the Las Vegas Strip. That is, if you know where to look. And, I’m not talking about Dominos or Pizza Hut. I’m talking about fresh New York-style pizza baked in a pizza oven with scratch made dough and tomato sauce.
So what makes a good New York slice? A slice should have just enough cheese and sauce to cover the thin crust which is both chewy and crispy. You want to taste each ingredient in every bite without any ingredients overpowering the other. While simple, each slice is a balancing act of flavors, textures, and colors.
On my recent visit to Las Vegas, I set out to find the best pizza slices on the strip. To keep the competition fair and see how each place matched up, I decided to order the same slice at each spot. And this was the ubiquitous pepperoni slice. This is my list of 9 of the best slices of pizza on the Las Vegas Strip.
1 – Secret Pizza
Looking for one of the best slices of New York-style pizza in Las Vegas? Look no further than Secret Pizza hidden inside the Cosmopolitan. It’s the perfect place for a slice before your night begins or after a night out. While not so secret these days, Secret Pizza can be tough to find and easy to walk by with no sign out front. With some of the best pizza in Las Vegas, the trouble to find it is worth it. If you manage to find the entrance located on the third floor of the Cosmo, follow the record-lined hallway to the walk-up counter. It is here where you can order a ready to go hot slice, create your own slice with your choice of toppings, or order a whole pie. After getting your pizza, grab a spot at the standing only counter inside or outside at one of the tables in the Cosmopolitan lounge area.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Secret Pizza: $5.75
Address: 3708 Las Vegas Blvd S Level 3, The Boulevard Tower, Las Vegas, NV 89109 (located in The Cosmopolitan)
Hours: Sunday-Thursday: 11:00AM-2:00AM; Friday-Saturday: 11:00AM-4:00AM
2 – Pin Up Pizza
If you are looking for the largest slice on the Las Vegas Strip, you come to Pin Up Pizza. This small pizzeria, located at Planet Hollywood, is popular for their New York-style slices. And, they are well known for the pin-up girls running the place behind the counter. The shop uses high quality ingredients including dough and pomodori pelati tomatoes flown in from Naples. Their Sorrento mozzarella comes from Buffalo, New York. But, the high quality ingredients come at a cost. Each slice will set you back $8.99. While not cheap, the slices are worth it, especially for the size. The dough is thin, chewy, and airy while crispy and smoky on the bottom. The tomato sauce is sweet and bright, adding in intense flavor to each bite. Covering the slice is the perfect amount of crispy, tender, rich pepperoni along with a layer of salty, fresh mozzarella. You can taste all the fresh ingredients in each bite. While expensive, this is one of the best slices on the strip. After you get your slice, grab one of the spots on the glass-enclosed patio for great views of the Las Vegas Strip.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Pin Up Pizza: $8.99
Pin Up Pizza
Address: 33667 S Las Vegas Blvd, Las Vegas, NV 89109 (located in Planet Hollywood)
Hours: Monday-Wednesday: 11:00AM-12:00AM; Thursday-Sunday: 11:00AM-2:00AM
3 – Pizza Cake
Pizza Cake is a New York-style pizzeria opened by celebrity chef and Cake Boss star Buddy Valastro. The small pizzeria opened in 2020 at Harrah’s, right on the Las Vegs Strip. Inside you will find checkerboard floors, subway tiles, and family photos on the walls. Like in New York, you can walk up and order a fresh slice, right out of the red pizza oven. With the help of his father-in-law, it took Buddy V six months to create his perfect slice of New York-style pizza. The crust here is thin and chewy with a crispy, charred bottom. Scattered around the slice are oily cups of spicy and salty pepperoni that adds the perfect richness. Also rich and salty is the fresh mozzarella baked into the crust. Finishing off this slice is a sweet and tart sauce that covers the entire slice. You can taste each ingredient in every bite. It’s all about attention to detail with the New York slices at Pizza Cake.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Pizza Cake: $6.95
Address: 3475 Las Vegas Blvd S, Las Vegas, NV 89109 (located in Harrah’s)
Hours: Sunday-Thursday: 12:00PM-12:00AM; Friday-Saturday: 12:00PM-4:00AM
4 – Flour & Barley
The next spot on my list of the best slices of pizza on the Las Vegas Strip brings us to Flour & Barley. Flour & Barley, located in The LINQ Promenade, specializes in brick oven pizzas and Italian inspired dishes. Their pepperoni slice features crunchy pieces of oil filled meat, tart and sweet tomato sauce, and a crispy but soft crust. They also have a happy hour beer & slice special for $8. This special is available at the walk-up window from 2:00PM to 6:00PM, Monday through Friday. While you are limited to cheese or pepperoni, the slices are large. After getting your slice, grab a spot at one of the standing tables out front or take a seat at the tables on the patio of the restaurant if available.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Flour & Barley: $5.50
Flour & Barley
Address: 3545 South Las Vegas Boulevard #L25, Las Vegas, NV 89109 (located in The LINQ Promenade)
Hours: Monday: 12:00PM-10:00PM; Tuesday-Wednesday: 11:00AM-10:00PM; Thursday-Saturday: 11:00AM-11:00PM; Sunday: 11:00AM-10:00PM
5 – Sirrico’s Pizza
Sirrico’s Pizza is a popular New York-style pizzeria located at the Village Street Eateries in New York-New York Hotel & Casino. It is not uncommon to find a line out front at any hour of the day. Sirrico’s uses a cafeteria ordering system, which is uncommon for pizzerias. You order at the counter and wait for your food before making your way to the front of the line to pay. The slices served here are large. The crust, which is thicker than a traditional New York slice, is chewy and pillowy with a smoky, charred bottom. Both the pepperoni and melted mozzarella add the right amount of rich, oily goodness. Balancing out this richness is a sweet and tart tomato sauce that covers the entire slice. Sirrico’s is the perfect spot for a quick, late night slice as long as the line isn’t too long.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Sirrico’s Pizza: $7.00
Address: 3790 S Las Vegas Blvd, Las Vegas, NV 89109 (located in New York-New York Hotel & Casino)
Hours: Sunday-Thursday: 11:00AM-2:00AM; Friday-Saturday: 11:00AM-3:00AM
6 – Slice of Vegas
Slice of Vegas is a busy pizzeria and Italian restaurant located at The Shoppes at Mandalay Place between Mandalay Bay and Luxor. The restaurant serves dishes including classic Italian favorites, sandwiches, pizza, salads, and more. But, if you don’t want to order a whole pie, or wait in line for a table, you can grab a slice from the small walk-up counter. Pizza selections include cheese, pepperoni, pepperoni and sausage, and supreme. You can also order a combo for $10 that gets you a slice, salad, and fountain drink. The slices served here are bigger and thicker than traditional New York-style pizza. The crust is doughy and chewy, almost like eating a calzone when folded. And, the slices are cheesy and gooey thanks to the generous amount of salty mozzarella. Also salty are the chewy pieces of spicy pepperoni which adds a rich injection of oily goodness. Bringing the slice together is a simple, fresh tomato sauce. With slices starting at $4.95, Slice of Vegas is a great spot for a slice on the southern section of the Las Vegas Strip.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Slice of Vegas: $5.45
Slice of Vegas
Address: 3930 Las Vegas Blvd S Suite 120, Las Vegas, NV 89119 (located in The Shoppes at Mandalay Place)
Hours: Sunday-Thursday: 11:00AM-10:00PM; Friday-Saturday: 11:00AM-11:00PM
7 – Rocco’s NY Pizza & Pasta
Rocco’s NY Pizza & Pasta is a local chain best known for their New York-style slices and Italian dishes. Rocco, who was born in the Bronx, learned to cook from his Italian family and eventually opened a deli and pizzeria in the New York area. He then moved to Las Vegas where he opened Rocco’s NY Pizza & Pasta. Today, there are six locations in the valley including one hidden in a strip mall across from Mandalay Bay. The menu at Rocco’s features a wide variety of Italian dishes including pizzas, sandwiches, stromboli, pasta, and salads. They also offer a variety of New York-style, thin crust slices. The slices, which are some of the thinnest on the strip, come out burning hot and crispy from the oven. The sauce is sweet and tart while the pepperoni is rich and greasy. If you are looking for a simple, no-frills pizzeria that feels miles away from the mega resorts then Rocco’s NY Pizza & Pasta is your spot.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Rocco’s NY Pizza & Pasta: $5.00
Rocco’s NY Pizza & Pasta
Address: 3999 S Las Vegas Blvd, Unit D, Las Vegas, NV 89119
Hours: Sunday-Thursday: 11:00AM-9:00PM; Friday-Saturday: 11:00AM-10:00PM
8 – Pizza D’Italia
I have walked past Pizza D’Italia more times than I can count without stopping, until recently. This no-frills pizza shop, located in the Miracle Mile Shops at Planet Hollywood, is often overlooked by those walking down the strip. While whole pies are insanely expensive, they do offer affordable $5.95 slices. Pizza options include pepperoni, margherita, cheese, Hawaiian, supreme, and veggie lovers. This isn’t your traditional New York-style slice but an Italian gourmet style pizza. Each slice uses 48 hour fermented homemade pizza dough. This dough is chewier and thicker than thin crust pizzas yet is still light and airy. Large pieces of spicy, smoky, and salty pepperoni, along with fresh basil, covers the entire slice. Under the pepperoni is a simple sweet tomato sauce and a sprinkling of shredded mozzarella. With only a counter to order at and no tables, you will need to find a place to enjoy your slice. I recommend somewhere on the Las Vegas Strip.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Pizza D’Italia: $5.95
Address: 3717 S Las Vegas Blvd, Las Vegas, NV 89109 (located in Miracle Mile Shops at Planet Hollywood)
Hours: Sunday-Thursday: 11:00AM-2:00AM; Friday-Saturday: 11:00AM-3:00AM
9 – Pisa Pizza
I debated whether to add Pisa Pizza to my list. But, I decided to add it anyways. So, the 9th and final spot on my list of the best slices of pizza on the Las Vegas Strip goes to Pisa Pizza. This pizzeria, borderline street food stall, takes up a small nook at the Grand Bazaar Shops in front of Bally’s. Pisa Pizza offers many stone baked Italian slices for around $5 to $6. Options include cheese, pepperoni, meat lovers, BBQ chicken, and Hawaiian. The homemade slices are simple yet large. The thin crust, while not as crispy as most slices, holds up to the big pieces of chewy pepperoni, thick layer of greasy mozzarella, and sweet tomato sauce. Other than pizzas, sides include nachos, pretzels, and a pizza dog. Sure, there are better places on the Las Vegas Strip for pizza with better service. But, with a prime location and late night hours, Pisa Pizza is a great spot for a quick and cheap bite after a night out.
Cost of a pepperoni slice at Pisa Pizza: $5.99
Address: 3635 S Las Vegas Blvd #103, Las Vegas, NV 89109 (located in Grand Bazaar Shops at Bally’s)
Hours: Sunday-Wednesday: 10:00AM-4:30AM; Friday-Saturday: 10:00AM-6:30AM